Episodes
Remember to Subscribe ๐๐ฝ๐๐ฝ, Rate, ๐๐ฝ and tell a ๐๐ฝ๐๐ฝfriend!
Episode 86: Sam Sheppard & The Murder of Marilyn Sheppard
July 2nd, 1954 - The peaceful town of Bay Village, Ohio, was rocked by a shocking crime: the wife of a beloved local surgeon was found brutally murdered in her bed just as the 4th of July weekend began. The doctor's improbable account of the attack, along with revelations of an affair, sparked a media firestorm that culminated in a landmark U.S. Supreme Court case and launched the career of one of America's most infamous defense attorneys.
Click โ hereโ for photos from the episode
Click โ hereโ for the Zillow listing
Click here for Crime Scene and Evidence Photos
Sources:
American Justice, S 5, Ep 3
https://www.famous-trials.com/sam-sheppard/18-sammarilysheppard
https://engagedscholarship.csuohio.edu/sheppard_whos_who/ย
Episode 85: Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
May 2nd, 1981 - When a prominent Georgian socialite, Jim Williams, is accused of murdering his secret lover, Danny Hansford, in a fit of rage, the charming city of Savannah, Georgia is shaken to its core. The ensuing *four* trials would not only set a record for the state, but would be some of the most sensational in its history. Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover a story so intriguing, it would inspire an award winning book and movie!
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here to see the home's website
Click here for the Zillow listing
Sources:
https://discover.hubpages.com/politics/The-Shooting-of-Danny-Hansfordย
Berendt, J. (1996). Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. Recorded Books, LLC.ย
Episodes 83 & 84: The Murder of Nicole Brown Simpson
June 12th, 1994 - The murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman set the nation on fire as millions watched the murder trial of celebrity and former-athlete OJ Simpson. Join hosts Terri and Julia as they delve into not only the grisly details of the crime but also uncover lesser-known facts and intriguing aspects of the investigation. From the tumultuous relationship between Nicole and O.J. Simpson to the riveting courtroom drama, Terri and Julia cover it all in this two part episode.ย
Sources:ย
Episodes 81 & 82: The Piketon Massacre
April 21, 2016 - When eight members of the Rhoden family are found dead inside of homes in three different locations, police are baffled. Was this the work of the cartel? A bad drug deal? Who would could ruthlessly kill so many, including teenagers as young as 16 and 19? Tune in to hear a story so full of twists and turns, it can't be covered all in one episode!
Click here for photos from the episode!
Sources:ย
Episode 80: The Taliesin Mansion Massacre
August 15th 1914 - Architectural masterpiece, Taliesin, was one of American architect Frank Lloyd Wright's proudest achievements. The sprawling estate was part workshop, part residence, and on this day, would become the site of an infamous massacre. Tune in to hear Julia and Terri dive deep into the life, loves, and legacy of Frank Lloyd Wright, and the tragedy that would forever haunt this mansion, now a preserved American Heritage Site!
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for Taliesin's website
Sources:
https://www.history.com/news/the-massacre-at-frank-lloyd-wrights-love-cottage
https://www.crimemuseum.org/crime-library/famous-murders/taliesin-massacre-frank-lloyd-wright/ย
Episodes 78 & 79: Gypsy Rose Blanchard
June 14th, 2015 - Delve into the twisted web of deception, abuse, and revenge as we unravel the shocking true story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard . Tune in to hear Julia and Terri's take on this infamous case and perhaps learn a few interesting facts!
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the home's listing
As mentioned in the episode - Do you need a yearly checkup?ย
Article interviewing neighbors close to the home
Sources:ย
Gypsyโs Revenge TV Show
Ep. 77: The Solved Cold Case of Rita Curran
July 20, 1971 - When school teacher Rita Curran is found brutally assaulted and murdered in the home she shared with several roommates, her case would set the record for Vermont's oldestย solved cold case. Join Terri and Julia as they explore the murder originally incorrectly attributed to Vermont native, Ted Bundy! TW: SA
Click here for photos from the episode
Sources:ย
https://www.cnn.com/2023/02/22/us/rita-curran-burlington-vermont-cold-case/index.htmlย
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/murder-rita-curran-william-deroos-solved-after-52-years-dna-cigarette-butt/
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2023/02/22/cold-case-solved-dna-cigarette-rita-curran/11320406002/
https://vermontdailychronicle.com/murder-of-hartland-womans-sister-finally-solved-after-50-years/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQPr9FKq3Jo&t=141sย
Ep. 76: The Carnation Christmas Eve Murders
December 24, 2007 - In the small town of Carnation, Washington, Judy and Wayne Anderson are planning a Christmas Eve get-together with all 10 members ofย their family. By the end of the night, six of them would be dead. Who would want to kill three generations of Andersons, and where are the other four family members? Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover this horrible holiday homicide, where all is not what it appears to be!
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here to see the home's Zillow listing
Brief recording of 911 call Erica made to police
Sources:
Homicide for the Holidays S.1 Ep. 2
https://censusreporter.org/profiles/16000US5310215-carnation-wa/ย
Ep. 75: The Mysterious Death of Ted Binion
September 17, 1998 - When a casino mogul from a well-known and powerful Las Vegas family is found dead in his home, all eyes are on his young girlfriend and shady business partner. But is the case that simple?ย Homicide, suicide, or accidental overdose? Tune in to hear about this case and draw your own conclusions!
Click here to see the mansion's Zillow Listing (with pictures)
Click here for photos from the episode
Sources:ย
On the Case with Paula Zahn, S.1 Ep. 6
Ep. 74: Family Annihilator Brad Bishop
March 2, 1976 - When police stumble across a ditch full of burnt bodies deep in the woods of North Carolina, they wonder: who are these victims and who would want to kill an entire family? Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover this case that would lead police to the Washington, DC suburb of Bethesda, Maryland, and place the killer on the FBI's Top Ten Most Wanted Fugitives.Stay tuned for bloopers!
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the home's listing (with photos)
Click here for the 1977 Washington Post article referenced in the episode
Article about Brad Bishop's long-lost daughter
Sources:
The Hunt with John Walsh, S.1 Ep. 3
Ep. 73: The Harrison Family Murders
April 16, 2009 - When Bill Harrison is found dead in his home, family members are suspicious, but police are slow to act. Meanwhile, as Canada struggles to keep its forensics program up to date, members of the Harrison family continue to die one by one. Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover this case of a personal vendetta that threatened to wipe out an entire family.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the home's listing
Sources:
https://projects.thestar.com/harrison-family-murders/
https://torontolife.com/city/house_of_horrors/
https://thepointer.com/article/2023-02-02/ordeal-continues-in-tragic-harrison-family-case-retrial-ordered-for-melissa-merritt-previously-found-guilty-in-murder-of-ex-husbandย
Ep. 72: The Thanksgiving Cannibalism Murder
November 28, 1991 - When 21-year-old Egyptian model, Omaima Nelson, married her 56-year-old Texan husband, Bill, all seemed well. However, just a few short weeks after their wedding on Thanksgiving Day, Omaima murdered him, chopped up his body, and cooked it for dinner. What led to this horrific murder? Join Julia and a special guest to learn about this infamous holiday homicide. TW: SA
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the apartment listing
Sources:
https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-12-03-me-526-story.htmlย
Snapped Season 14, Episode 1
Ep. 71: The Double Homicide of Jack and Linda Myers
March 27, 2003 - When a four year old shows up to daycare an hour late and covered in blood, alarm bells ring in the small village of Bradford, Ohio. Join Julia and Terri as they explore how forensics helped solve the horrifying double homicide of a business-savvy and well loved husband and wife.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the Zillow Listing
Sources:ย
https://forensicfilesnow.com/index.php/2019/07/12/jack-and-linda-myers-killed-for-the-farm/
Forensic Files - Season 12, episode 20
Ep. 70: The Controversial "Castle Doctrine" Case of Byron David Smith
November 22, 2012 - On Thanksgiving Day, veteran Byron David Smith kills two teenage intruders in cold blood -- but was there more to the case? Listener, beware! Mother and Daughter do not agree about the outcome of this controversial case! Lot of shennanigans in the beginning -- the case starts around 12:00.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here to hear the audio evidence
Click here to view the home's Zillow listing
Sources:
https://www.justiceforbyronsmith.com/homeย
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=waswKMganjIย
https://wjon.com/byron-smith-murder-trial-case-sent-to-jury/ย
Ep. 69: Franklin Castle
It's spooky season and who doesn't love a good haunted mansion tale? In this short episode, Julia and Terri go back to 1881 Celeveland to cover one of the most haunted sites in all of Ohio. Ghosts of children, dead mobsters, and a lady in Black all are said to reside in this famous historic property. Tune in to learn about the original owner of the home who was suspected of killing family members as well as servants in the house, as well as subsequent owners including Judy Garland's 5th husband!
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here to visit Franklin Castle's official website
Click here to book an overnight stay!
Sources:ย
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/6593341/hannes-tiedemann
https://clevelandhistorical.org/items/show/531ย
https://allthatsinteresting.com/franklin-castleย
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifRMFK3ixbk
https://www.thetravel.com/where-are-there-castles-in-ohio/#great-stone-castleย
Ep. 68: Delphine De LaLaurie's House of Horrors
April 10, 1834 - When fire ravages the mansion of one of New Orleans' most prominent socialites, police and firefighters arrive to a shocking scene. What they find inside is a house of horrors that would go down as one of the most horrific crime scenes in American history. Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover the true story behind one of the nation's most haunted houses -- one so infamous, it was featured in an entire season of American Horror Story!ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the Zillow Listing
Click here for the article on the current owner and home's remodel
Sources:ย
Madame Delphine LaLaurie: The Myth and the Mystery - YouTube
From Socialite to Serial Killer - Mad Madame LaLaurie - YouTube
Madame Delphine LaLaurie (Serial Killer History Explained) - YouTube
Mistress of the Haunted House - 64 Parishes
LaLaurie Mansion | Haunted LaLaurie House (ghostcitytours.com)
https://www.neworleans.com/travel-professionals/did-you-know-new-orleans-facts/ย
Ep. 66 & 67: Lizzie Borden
August 4th, 1892 - Did Lizzie Borden take an axe and give her mother 40 whacks? It's spooky season and this October, join Julia and Terri as they cover some of the most infamous murder cases and murder houses in the country! For two weeks, we'll do a deep dive into Lizzie Borden, her family, the infamous murder, and the Fall River, Massachusetts home where it all happened.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the home's website
Click here to see the haunting reports and "visual evidence" of haunting
Sources:ย
Ep. 65: Mary and Matthew Winkler
March 22, 2006 - When a pastor fails to show up for Wednesday bible study, worried parishioners go to his home to check on him. What they find is a bloody crime scene that would leave them wondering, who would want to kill the beloved reverend? Tune in to this episode to hear Terri and Julia cover this case which would capture the attention of Oprah, Men's rights activists, and armchair psychologists across the country.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the home's Zillow listing
Click here to see Mary's interview with Oprah
Sources:ย
https://murderpedia.org/female.W/w/winkler-mary.htm
https://abcnews.go.com/2020/story?id=3350281&page=1
Ep. 64: The Disappearance of Paul Gruber
February 1994 - Paul Gruber seemed to be living the dream! A large inheritance led him to an early retirement and a house on a lake in Sandpoint, Idaho. But when his loving daughter can't get a hold of him after several weeks, she suspects foul play. Tune in to hear Terri and Julia cover this case that stumped police for month, before they found the answer was right under their noses (or should we say, feet?)
Click here for photos from the episode
Sources:
Forensic Files Season 11, Episode 28 - If I Were You
https://thecinemaholic.com/paul-gruber-murder-where-is-darryl-kuehl-now/ย
Ep. 63: The Easter Sunday Massacre
March 30, 1975 - On a quiet Easter Sunday evening, police are called to the home of Charity Ruppert where they find the aftermath of a rampage that left 11 people dead. What would cause someone to kill their entire family, including eight children? Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover this case, which would go down in history as the deadliest shooting by a lone gunman in Ohio and hear about what happened to the infamous house afterward.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the article with Cinnamon Baker
Click here for the home's listing
Other Sources:ย
Ep. 62: The Controversial Death of Tamla Horsford
November 3, 2018 - When a southern, white, suburban mother hosts a large sleepover that leaves the only attendee of color dead, people are left wondering, was this a tragic accident or heinous murder? Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover a story that grabbed the attention of the nation as everyone tried to figure out, what really happened to Tamala Horsford? TW: SA
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here to see the home's listing with photos of the balcony
Click here for the Rolling Stone article mentioned in the episode
Sources:
Ep. 61: The Mysterious Disappearance of Jennifer Teague
September 8, 2005 - When 18 year old Jennifer Teague disappears walking home from a late night shift at work, the suburb of Barrhaven is put on high alert and police launch one of the most notorious investigations in Canadian history. Tune in to learn more about Jennifer Teague and the meticulous policework that led to the arrest of an unlikely killer. TW: SA.ย
Sources:ย
The Case that Haunts Me, Season 2, Episode 1
Ep. 60: The Disappearance of Tara Grinstead
October 24th, 2005 - Tara Grinstead is an ambitious and beautiful high school teacher, pageant title holder, and beloved community member in the tiny town of Oscilla, Georgia. When she fails to show up to teach class on a Monday morning, alarm bells ring! Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover this case that spanned almost two decades and has a shocking ending.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the home's Zillow listing
Listen to Season 1 of Up and Vanished
Sources:ย
Ep. 59: The Fitbit Murder of Connie Dabate
December 23, 2015 - Just two days before Christmas, 911 receives a call and dispatches police to the home of Richard and Connie Dabate. What they find is a sinister crime scene that left investigators wondering, who would want to kill a beloved wife and mother of two? Tune in to hear Julia and Terri cover the story ofย what seemed like a picture perfect couple, and the unlikely way this murder was solved!
Sources:
Dateline Episode: The Secrets of Birch View Drive
https://www.sportskeeda.com/pop-culture/nbc-dateline-what-happened-connie-dabateย ย
Ep. 58: Johnny Lewis & the Murder of Catherine Davis
September 26, 2012 - When a promising young actor is found dead outside of a home where his landlady has been murdered, questions abound. Tune in to hear the tragic story of Sons of Anarchy star Johnny Lewis, and a downward spiral that shocked Hollywood and ended in homicide.ย
Click here for photos from the show
Click here for the TMZ pictures mentioned in the episode
Click here for the home's Zillow listing
Sources:ย
Ep. 57: The Groene Family Massacre
May 16, 2005 - A triple homicide is only part of the horrific story when police in Coeur dโAlene, Idaho discover half a family slain and two young children missing. Tune in to hear about the story of the Groene Family, which sparked national alarm and put police on the trail of a potential serial killer. TW: SA, Child Abuse
Sources:
People Magazine Investigates - Season 6, Episode 1
https://bonnercountydailybee.com/news/2018/jun/17/face-to-face-on-her-terms-7/ย
Episodes 55 & 56: Susan and Joshua Powell
December 7, 2009 - When a beloved wife and mother of two goes missing in West Valley City, Utah, all eyes are on her husband with a troubled past. His behavior and unlikely alibi make him the #1 suspect, but what can authorities do without a body? Tune in to this two part episode to hear about the disappearance of Susan Powell and the tragic ending to her family's story. TW: CP, SA, Child Abuse, Suicide
Click here for the Zillow listing of the Powell Family home
Click here for the old listing for Josh's rentalย
Click here for photos from the case
Click here for the Inside Edition article with Steve's song lyrics
Stephen's house sold to victims article
Sources:ย
West Valley Crime data: https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ut/west-valley-city/crime#descriptionย
https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=53483190&itype=CMSIDย
How it Really Happened, Season 4, Episodes 1 & 2
The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell on Oxygen
Ep. 54: The Murder of Philip Gattusoย
October 26, 2009 - When a beloved father and recent widower is found bludgeoned to death in his bedroom, police in Fargo, North Dakota move quickly to find who committed this ruthless midday murder. Join Terri and Julia as they cover how police were able to use surveillance footage to uncover a surprising suspect and shocking motive.ย
Sources:
Episodes 52 & 53: Betty Broderick & the Murders of Dan Broderick and Linda Kolkena
ย November 5th, 1989 - When an affair leads to one of the messiest divorces in California history, what follows is a vicious double homicide. Tune in to episode one to hear about the rise and fall of the marriage of a seemingly happy, wealthy couple, a salacious affair, and acrimonious divorce. Follow up with episode two to hear about the murders, the *two trials* inspired media frenzy and coverage from Law & Order to Oprah, and details about the home where it happened. TW: Self-harmย
Sources:
https://murderpedia.org/female.B/b/broderick-betty.htmย
https://www.latimes.com/la-me-broderick3jun0390-story.htmlย
Ep. 51: Love & Death - The Murder of Betty Gore
June 13, 1980 - When concerned husband, Allan Gore,ย is on a business trip and has a hard time getting in touch with his wife, he asks neighbors to check on her. After they discover her body riddled with 41 ax blows, what follows is story of a salacious love affair and a riveting trial that shocked the small town of Wylie, Texas. Join Julia and Terri as they cover this case which has inspired movies and TV shows alike.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Texas Monthly Article mentioned in the episode
Current photos of the house
House listing from Realtor.com
Sources:ย
Episodes 49 & 50: The Clutter Family "In Cold Blood" Murders
November 15, 1959 - When the bodies of four members of a wealthy and well-respected family are found in their home, a small town of 250 people is set on edge. When famous author Truman Capote becomes intrigued with the case, he fascinates a nation by covering the case in his book In Cold Blood. Join Julia and Terri as they explore the murders credited with birthing the True Crime genre. TW: SA
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here for the home listingย
Article with information about owners of the home
Article with the perps' last wordsย ย
Sources:ย
https://www.truecrimeedition.com/post/the-clutter-family-murdersย
Cold Blooded: The Clutter Family Murdersย
https://law.justia.com/cases/kansas/supreme-court/1961/42-068-0.htmlย ย
https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-procedure/the-insanity-defense-among-the-states.htmlย ย
Ep. 48: The Murder of Emma Walker
November 21, 2016 - Around 6am, a mother goes into her teenage daughter's room to wake her for school. When she appears to be sleeping peacefully but is unresponsive, police are unsure about how she died and who would want to harm this popular, honor-roll cheerleader. Join Terri and Julia as they cover this case that stumped police and the residents of a small town in Knoxville, until dark secrets about a toxic teenage love affair are revealed.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Click here to see the secret sting recordings from Alex and Noah played in court
Sources:
Ep. 47: The Menendez Brothers
August 20, 1989 - When two handsome brothers from Beverly Hills go on a spending spree shortly after finding both of their parents murdered in their home, all eyes are on the privileged duo. What followed was a court case and trial that captivated America. Tune in as Julia and Terri do a deep dive into this crime and the multi- million home where it happened. TW: SA
Stay tuned for bloopers!
Sources:ย
The Crimes that Changed Us - S 1 Ep. 4
Crime Files The Homefront - S 1 Ep. 2
Episodes 45 & 46: Jodi Arias and the Murder of Travis Alexander
June 9, 2008 - A well-liked and charismatic eligible bachelor hasn't been heard from in several days and a friend raises the alarm when he fails to correspond about their upcoming vacation. In our one year anniversary episode, Julia and Terri recount one of the most memorable and salacious murder cases of all time. In a case too big to cover in one episode, tune in to hear our hosts recount a trial for the ages -- one which they watched together from gavel to gavel.ย
Ep. 44: The Home Invasion and Murders of Bud & Melanie Billings
July 9, 2009 - Authorities are called to the home of Bryd "Bud" and Melanie Billings, a couple well known in their community for their business acumen and large family of 16 children, many of whom have special needs. Bud and Melanie are found shot in their bedroom and the attack happened while six of their children were home. The home invasion and murders were so swift and organized, they would soon be dubbed "The Ninja Killings". Join Terri and Julia as they dive into this case where investigators were determined to find out who would kill this beloved couple, and why?ย
Sources:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murders_of_Byrd_and_Melanie_Billingsย
https://www.thezebra.com/resources/research/burglary-statistics/ย ย
https://www.forbes.com/home-improvement/home-security/home-invasion-statistics/ย ย ย
Floribama Murders, Season 1, Episode 4
Ep. 43: Preston Murr & The Boise Murder House
June 30, 1987 - When a neighbor is awakened by banging and screaming by a bloody man on his front porch, he calls the police but they fail to show up. The next day, neighbors are shocked to find blood trailing down their quiet neighborhood street and on their own doorsteps! What follows is a tale of a missing guns, drugs, money, and a brutal body dismemberment in the basement of a beautiful 20th century home. Join Julia and Terri as they dive into Boise's most infamous murder house. (Case starts around 9:30 if you want to skip Julia and Terri's mother/daughter banter!)
Sources:
Episodes 41 & 42: Gregg and Pamela Smart
May 1, 1990 - When a 24 year old newlywed is found murdered in the front hallway of his home, the small town of Derry, New Hampshire is put on edge. Soon, all eyes are on his 22 year old teacher wife and the 15 year old student with whom she was having an affair. What follows is one of the most watched trials of all time. In a story too big to cover in one episode, join Julia and Terri as they dig into this case that would make United States (and true crime) history!
Ep. 40: The Murder of Rhonda Oakley
August 31, 2016 - A son discovers his stepmother stabbed to death in the basement of their Kentucky home and his 15-year-old sister, Jenna, is nowhere to be found. Join our hosts as they explore this case and attempt to find the answer to the question: Was Jenna responsible for the homicide or another victim?ย
Ep. 39: Ryan Waller & Heather Quan
December 25th, 2006 - When a beloved son and his childhood sweetheart fail to show up for Christmas dinner, what follows is a case for the ages that would put a spotlight on the questionable decisions made by police in Maricopa, AZ. Join Julia and Terri as they cover this investigation and the unfortunate assumptions that would eventually compound the tragic circumstances of this murder.ย
Click here to see the full video of Ryan's Interrogation
YouTube video referenced in the episode (Ryan's dad's interview and investigation into Phoenix PD)
Click here for photos from the episode
Ep. 38: The Controversial Death of Dave Laut
August 27, 2009 - When a former Olympian is found slain in his backyard after his wife reports a prowler, the question isn't who killed him but why? Join our hosts as they take a deep dive into this case that could have some listeners wondering whether they side with the killer.ย
Zillow home listing
Click here for photos from the episode
Learn more about this case by watching Dateline - Season 24, Episode 35
Ep. 37: Tequila Suter
February 15, 2014 - A woman is found murdered in her home in Lackawanna, New York. Police hit several dead ends before they can piece together who stabbed this kindhearted, church-going friend and daughter 39 times. Join Terri and Julia as they explore this gruesome Valentines Day murder.ย
Ep.36: The Alexandria Serial Killer
November 11, 2013 - A well-loved father and husband is found murdered in his home and detectives discover evidence similar to a crime that occurred nearly 10 years before. Can police connect the dots between murders in this affluent Washington, DC suburb? Join us for an episode so close to home, one of our co-hosts knew a victim in this decades-long case.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Washingtonian Article Referenced in episode: Does a Gruesome Murder Lessen a Houseโs Resale Value?
Listing for Ronald Kirby's home
Listing for Ruthanne Lodato's home
Listing for Nancy Dunning's home
Ep. 35: The Disappearance of Kristin Smart
May 25, 1996 - When a 19 year old freshman at California Polytechnic State University is reported missing, campus police are slow to begin their investigation, leading to a series of mistakes that would cause their investigation to span nearly 30 years. Join Julia and Terri as they unpack one of the most notorious and consequential missing persons cases in US history. TW: SA
Click here for photos from the episode
Listing for Susan Flores's "Planter Box" house (Zillow)
Click here for an excellent NPR article we used for source material
For more information, check out the podcast In Your Own Backyard which is a podcast solely dedicated to Kristin Smart's case
Ep. 34: The Wellnitz Family Murders
February 26, 1993 - The sleepy town of Columbia, Kentucky is shaken when a popular veterinarian, his wife, and son are all found shot to death in their country home. Is it the occult, an upset pet owner, or something else entirely unexpected? Join Terri and Julia as they explore this southern triple homicide that was so baffling, it took nearly 10 years to solve.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Ep. 33: The Murder of Anne Marie Fahey
June 27th, 1996 - When a promising young woman goes missing in Wilmington, Delaware, police struggle to pin down a wealthy, well-connected attorney although they have little physical evidence and no body. Join Terri and Julia as cover this twisty, turny case that puts a prominent family in the spotlight and spans across multiple states.ย
November 10th, 2010 - When a woman goes missing along with her children and a neighbor, police discover aย house covered in blood but containing no bodies. Detectives are stumped as they attempt to solve what they assume is a case of multiple homicides. Join Julia and Terri as they explore a story that leads them to exploring TWO houses - a murder house and a bizarre house of leaves. TW: SA
Click here for photos from the episode
Tina Hermann's Home (Zillow)
Matthew Hoffman's Home (Zillow)
When a popular 16-year-old girl is found brutally murdered in her family's kitchen, police are stumped as to who could have wanted to kill her. After a series of dead-ends, detectives work to solve the case before it goes cold. Join Julia and Terri as they explore close-to-home crime in the military town of Portsmouth, Virginia.ย
TW: CP, SA
Click here for photos from the episode
December 29, 2014 - Police in the city of Edmonton, Canada receive a series of 911 calls. A soccer mom has been shot in front of her children and a house full of bodies is found just miles away. Who are the victims? Are the murders related -- and if so, how and what's the motive? Join Julia and Terri as they dive deep into a crime that would be one of the worst mass murders in Canada's history.ย
December 24, 2008 - A family's annual Christmas Eve party is interrupted when Santa Claus arrives with two guns and a homemade flamethrower. Join Julia and Terri as they cover this tragic Christmas Eve story, detailing what happens when family ties go awry. TW: Suicide (call 988 for the Suicide Prevention Hotline)
Click here for photos from the episode
Check out our guest spot on the Real Estate Podcast Show
April 17, 2011 - Following months of a tumultuous relationship between her teenage son and his girlfriend, a mother becomes worried when her child fails to return home and is not answering her calls. Join Terri and Julia as they explore a case of a teenage love triangle gone wrong.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
December 25, 1996 - One of the most infamous unsolved murders of all time occurs when a 6-year-old beauty queen is found dead in the basement of her Boulder, Colorado home. Join Terri and Julia as they dive into the murder, the suspects and theories, and the multimillion dollar home where it all happened.ย
November 26, 2009 - When someone invites a long-estranged family member to Thanksgiving, dinner ends in bloodshed. Join Julia and Terri as they unpack the case that shook the happy beachside town of Jupiter, Florida, leading to a five-week-long manhunt and forever changing a family. TW: Mental Health, Suicide
August 22, 1922 - Suspecting his house is haunted, a man and his wife move from Milwaukee to Los Angeles, only to continue being tormented by what seem like ghostly spirits! Shortly afterwards, he is shot dead in his new home overlooking Sunset Boulevard. Who did it? How? Join Julia and Terri as they dig into this bizarre historical tale that proves you can never truly know who you're married to... or what may be lurking upstairs.ย
October 30, 1982 - Up-and-coming actress and star of the film Poltergeist, Dominique Dunne, is found strangled at her West Hollywood home. What would follow next is a trial for the ages, a family's fight for justice, and a spooky film legacy. Join Julia and Terri as they explore one of Hollywood's most tragic murders.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Vanity Fair article written by Dominick Dunne mentioned in the episode
June 9th, 1912 - After returning from an evening church service, a family of six and two house guests are found hacked to death in a home in small-town Iowa. Join Terri and Julia as they explore one of the most notorious unsolved crimes of the century, lay out the suspects, and the dive into the history of the house where the murders took place!
Video Tour of the House
Visit or book your stay in the home here
Click here for photos from the episode
January 23, 1897 - A woman is declared deceased with her cause of death is listed as "everlasting faint", but when her ghost appears several days later and starts pointing fingers at her accused murderer, things get spooky real fast! Travel to West Virginia with Terri and Julia as they explore a case written in the annals of history as the only time a ghost has helped solve a murder!ย
Click here for photos from the episode
July 13th, 2011 - A woman is found hanging from the second floor balcony of a multimillion dollar home under extremely suspicious circumstances -- yet the police declare her death a suicide against family and public outcry to investigate her death as a homicide. What's even more bizzare? Just two days before discovering her body, the home had been the scene of the death of a six year old child. Join Terri and Julia forย a case too big to fit into one episode!
TW: Suicide, SA
August 23rd, 2006 - A successful pharmaceutical executive is brutally murdered in his million dollar home while on the phone with his fiancรฉ. The defense of his accused murderer would go down in history as one of the most bizarre in history. Join Julia and Terri as they dig into this murder and the man who claimed he was "too old, too sick, too fat" to have committed the crime.ย
July 22, 2015 - A 911 operator receives a phone call from a whispering child, begging for help as he hides in his bedroom.ย Minutes later, police stumble upon a gruesome scene that would forever fracture a close family of nine. Join Julia and Terri as they dive into this heartbreaking event and explore what became of the home where the tragedy occurred.
See photos from the episode here
November 29, 2006 - A pregnant woman, months away from her wedding day is found slain in the garage of the house she just bought with her fiancรฉ. He's the primary suspect, but is there more to this story? Join Terri and Julia as they dive into this case, in which the "Pride of Mississippi" was put on trial.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
July 16, 2011 - A troubled teen hosts a blowout house party for over 100 people at his family's home... but where are his parents? Join Terri and Julia as they recount the tragic tale of an incident dubbed by many as a truly "killer" party.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
Rolling Stone article mentioned in the episode
Deathpenaltyinfo.org ย - mentioned in episode
November 16, 2006 - A kind and generous illiterate day laborer plays the lottery and becomes a millionaire overnight. Less than three years later, his body would be found buried in five feet of dirt under a concrete slab in the backyard of a single family home. Join Terri and Julia as they explore the tragic tale of Abraham Shakespeare, one of the world's most unlucky lottery winners.ย
November 8, 2010 - A young woman frantically calls 911. She says her family has been robbed and she's tied up and hears gunshots from downstairs... but is all as it appears to be? Join Terri and Julia as they explore this bizarre tale which put a microscope on the controversial practice of "tiger parenting".ย
Click here for photos from the episode
October 12, 2016 - A beautiful 24-year-old woman with a promising future is brutally murdered in her UK flat by her ex-boyfriend after contacting the police multiple times to warn them about his behavior. Tune in to hear the details of the this case which would change the future of UK stalking laws.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
December 30th 2000 - Weeks away from moving out of their house, the Miyazawa family is found brutally massacred in their Tokyo suburb home. Join Julia and Terri as they cover Tokyo's highest profile murder case involving 246,044 investigators who have collected over 12,545 pieces of evidence and remains unsolved after 22 years.ย
Video tour of home
Click here for photos from the episode
ย October 17th 2006 - A man's body is found on the rooftop of the Omni Royal Orleans Hotel in New Orleans. In his pocket? A confession to a murder so gruesome, it would be come a staple of New Orleans true crime tourism for years to come. Join us to hear about a murder house that Julia has actually been inside of!
Click here to view photos from the episode
June 10, 2016 - A 911 operator in Gresham, Oregon receives a horrific phone call from a woman saying that she has been stabbed "all over". Tune in to hear about this bizarre case involving polyamory, pirates, and plenty 'o roommates!
May 14, 2015 - A quadruple homicide in one of Washington DC's most upscale neighborhoods and only blocks away from the Vice President's mansion sends the city reeling. Tune in to this episode to hear Julia and Terri take a deep dive into this horrific "hometown" homicide and what became of the multimillion dollar home in which it took place.ย
Washington Post Article on the house's hard selling history
11 Episode podcast on this crime from WTOP
Click here to view photos from the episode
November 13, 1974 - One of the most notorious family massacres in American history takes place in the quiet, affluent, seaside town of Amityville, NY. Join Julia and Terri as they dissect the murders, the the claims of hauntings that followed the brutal massacre, and explore the infamous home that would inspire books and movies for years to come.ย
October 24, 2011 - A 12 year old boy is found strangled in the apartment in he shares with his mother and brother. A mystery TOO BIG too contain in one episode, join Terri and Julia as they delve into a story that rocked the nation along racial and political lines as everyone tries to solve the mystery of who murdered Garrett Phillips.ย
Click here for photos from the episodeย
Watch Who Murdered Garret Phillips? on HBO
Police Video of Nick Hillary "limping"
April 29th, 1989 - It's prom night in the tiny town of Lakeville, Indiana, and no one expects that a horrific quadruple homicide will occur in the parsonage of the local church. Join Terri and Julia as they explore this small town and the murder that changed it forever when a local teen is thrust into a controversial trial over the murder of his family.ย
Click here for photos from the episode
See Jeff's interrogation video here.
Want more? Check out Season 3 of Counter Clock!
September 22nd, 2006 - A beautiful young woman with a promising future is found stabbed in the living room of her aunt and uncle's home after a weekend housesitting. Join Julia and Terri as they dive deep into this gruesome crime, 'inspired' by one of the most popular horror franchises of all time.ย ย
Click here for photos from the episode.
May 5th, 2009 - A mother and her two sons are found strangled in a beautiful home in suburbia. Join Julia and Terri as they take a deep dive into a case that shook the town of Columbia, Illinois to its core, and revealed what hid behind the closed doors of this perfect All-American family.
Click here for photos from the episode!ย
February 2nd, 2008 - Beautiful, 24-year-old realtor, Lindsay Buziak, is murdered while showing a home to a mysterious couple. Join Julia and Terri as they take a deep dive into this unsolved murder, explore theories, and speak with a seasoned realtor who gives us her perspective on the case, shares her scariest realtor experiences, and gives some safety tips and tricks!ย
Click here for photos from the episode!
September 15th, 2009 - A horrific quadruple homicide rocks the town of Farmville, Virginia. Join Julia and Terri as they take a deep dive into these murders and the place where they happened. ย
Click here for photos from the episode!